![]()
Two Sides of the Story
Two different facts are being discussed in the news about suicides in prestigious institutions like the IITs. The first is that some students who entered through reservation with lower marks and ranks find it hard to keep pace with the toppers. The second is that faculty members harass SC and ST students. Both need to be examined calmly and from more than one angle.
When the Celebration Ends
A student who gets into an IIT is welcomed with great joy by family and society. Coaching institutes also celebrate the success, partly for their own benefit. But once the glamour of selection fades, the real challenge begins. Good grades and campus placements depend on ability, and there is no reservation in exams or in the placement process. Every student must compete with everyone else.
Some students struggle here and slowly slip into depression. It is often reported that this stage begins from the second year. The struggle is not caused by marks and ranks alone. Many students come from small towns and villages, where they studied in their own language, so teaching in English can be a real difficulty. They may feel isolated among classmates from very different backgrounds. Being far away from family for the first time adds to their loneliness. Family expectations, social pressure and the difficulty of dealing with male and female classmates can make things worse. Those who cannot bear the pressure sometimes take the most painful decision of all.
Counselling Is the Need of the Hour
Nothing is more important than life. Every problem in life can be managed, but a lost life cannot be brought back. Every institution must therefore give proper psychological counselling to its students.
At the start of each session, all students should be counselled about what lies ahead. They should be told that the coming years will not be easy and that admission is only the first step. A committee should be formed to look into the problems of students. If a student’s condition worsens, the parents should be called in for counselling too.
The Question of Harassment
I find it hard to believe that faculty members deliberately harass SC and ST students. Most professors hardly know the names of their students unless a student becomes famous for some reason. Meeting the Director is almost impossible, as he is one of the busiest persons in the institution. Such allegations should be investigated fairly, without assuming anything in advance.
Shortage of Faculty
The IITs already have fewer teachers than they need. If faculty members, or even the Director, are asked to resign, the institutions will face another serious setback. These teachers are highly qualified and could easily find better opportunities in foreign universities. If they leave, the blame game will only get worse. The government must be careful and deal with the main issues instead of simply asking people to go.
Blame Game and Politics
The difficulty is that people take sides, either with reserved category students or with faculty members. When general category students commit suicide, there is not much noise. It seems political gain also plays a part in this blame game.
The Way Forward
Newspapers report from time to time that Parliament discusses dropout rates, and that many reserved category students have not done as well as expected. The question is what should finally be done for such students. The biggest burden of the solution lies with psychological counselling, given early and with care.
Reference
Very balanced article, sir. As you said counselling is the need of the hour. Getting into an IIT is a matter of pride for any student, but a few can actually cope with the work load is another matter. Securing admission based on reservations makes it even more challenging – not trying to run anyone down but that’s how it is. Also, the faculty in IITs is very sensitive about making derogatory remarks on students, so not sure how far that allegation goes. More than the faculty it’s the fellow students who demoralize by indulging in hazing or ragging – have many IIT friends who have confirmed this. But again the need of the hour is not finger pointing and political bickering – it’s sitting across the table and sorting this out amicably.
Dear Guar ji..
A very timely and thought-provoking article. No degree, rank or career is worth the price of a life. Academic institutions must look beyond marks and placements and give equal importance to mental well-being, counselling and emotional support. Early intervention, empathy and a supportive environment can save lives. Ultimately, education should build lives—not break them…
Politicians want to take milage on it and add color of caste and make it sensitive to the public for votes ..
This would never end in INDIA..
Comment by T. V. Raveendran, Bangaluru